I had a business trip over the last few days so I watched the latest Indiana Jones movie on the plane.
Not quite as bad as Crystal Skull, but not a good movie. Everything kind of felt forced, like they needed to put a reference to the original movies in every other scene. Ford was fine, the woman playing his goddaughter was fine as an actress, but they tried to hard to make her be a super-genius con artist who still needed to be rescued by an 80-year-old archeologist.
They leaned too hard into the woo-woo time travel magic stuff that didn't really have any explanation except "Archimedes was a math genius and time travel is all math." The first three movies worked a little better with the supernatural elements because they were deeply tied into religious traditions. It somehow feels more "realistic" if you're seeking an ancient relic that is the subject of an ancient religious text or legend (though the Sankara Stones were not "real," you could tell the writers drew deep on Indian mythology to describe their importance). Crystal skulls and the Antikythera mechanism just don't carry the same kind of gravitas.
I still think they could recast the character and have other adventures with him in his prime. Having most of the film set in the 1960s seems a little too "modern" to me. It's more mysterious and exotic if the adventures are pre-WWII. Like, do we really need to see the iconic map with the line when he's traveling by commercial jet? And because of his age, he didn't have as many good fighting scenes, although Indy did throw a few punches. They wasted a chance to use the comically-overmuscled henchman, who didn't really fight anyone.
Oh, and this didn't make any sense at all (spoilered as it describes specific plot elements):
When Indy and crew get away on the boat, they head west toward Sicily rather than toward Alexandria, where the bad guys were supposed to go. The bad guys realized Indy's not going to Alexandria, but was generally going west and decided to follow. How did they know exactly which town Indy was headed? Lucky guess? If they followed in sight of Indy's boat, I would imagine that they would have been spotted.
Maybe they figured it out based on other clues, I can kind of accept that.
But what I can't accept is that after the bad guys get all the pieces to the titular Dial of Destiny, they make their escape, via a cargo van, to a nearby airfield and hangar where they had secreted a WWII-era bomber and another 20 or so henchmen, all in vintage nazi uniforms. Their plan was to go back in time to 1939, fly to Germany and kill Hitler. How did they know they were going to find the last part of the Dial in Sicily? For all they knew, it was going to be in Alexandria or somewhere else. It all seems like an elaborately-planned operation that could have easily been carried out anywhere. How did they know they'd be in Sicily?
For that matter, how did they know that the Dial was going to open up a "time fissure" in the sky, so they'd need an airplane? None of this shit makes sense.
In short, 2/57 dickbutts. One bright spot was a character played by Antonio Banderas, who is still pretty charismatic even though he's getting older, too.
Agree with the issues.
The positives: I like that they based the villain on Operation Paperclip and his motive was unique. I liked the nod to Archimedes discover of water displacement to calculate volume of an object. And I liked that the Antikythera, being a real historical relic, was the focus instead of purely supernatural items that we don't know if they existed or not. Oh, I also like that they got time travel right. As soon as I saw
the watch on archimedes, I figured out where it was going. They could never change history, so they got time the time travel paradox right. All they did was fulfill history that has already happened, so I could appreciate that
I noticed the same issues you did. Major plot holes just to move it along. Oh he's going west. Wait, the boat was damaged and you're just watching them go the entire way in your binos? WTF? Usually there are explanations for how the bad guys show up at the same place, but in this case, every single time it was just "They went there". Like near the tomb, they climbed up there! How the fuck did you know that? Footprints on the cave wall? I don't buy that he figured it one in 1 second based on the light.
You missed one though that stood out worse than any of the rest to me.
Can you fly that (whatever type of plane that was)? I don't know. I've never flown a plane. Yes I can. Then he hotwires a plane, figures out instruments, takes off and flies in a terrible storm without having ever flown a plane? That was just retarded.
I didn't even notice Banderas.